From tearful auditions to awkward eliminations, Carrie Underwood never looked fully comfortable behind that judges’ desk ...

Following her 'American Idol' Season 4 win, Carrie Underwood made history after debuting as a judge on Season 23, bringing her journey full circle. Since winning the title in 2005, Underwood has ...

Carrie Underwood brought honesty to the panel, now it’s time to replace longtime judges with true 'American Idol' alumni who know the grind ...